A WEIRD timing Guðbjörg Lára Másdóttir og Aldo Marchiano Kaligis skrifa 23. nóvember 2023 12:00 Over the recent weeks, several leaders from the WEIRD (White/Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Developed/Democratic) world have expressed criticism for Israel's indiscriminate attacks in the occupied Palestinian territory (oPt). On 10 November 2023, Belgian Prime Minister Alexander De Croo characterized Israel's actions in Gaza as "disproportionate." French President Emmanuel Macron echoed this sentiment on 11 November, stating that there was "no justification" for the bombings and saying a ceasefire would benefit Israel while recognizing Israel's right to protect itself. On 15 November 2023, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez called on Israel to halt the "indiscriminate killing of Palestinians" in Gaza. The following day, Iceland Prime Minister Katrín Jakobsdóttir said she was "horrified by the ongoing civilian deaths in Gaza" and condemned all breaches of international humanitarian law. Despite the apparent solidarity, it's crucial to scrutinize the context and actions accompanying these condemnations. Unlike non-WEIRD leaders who swiftly condemned Israel's disproportionate retaliatory actions following the 7 October 2023 Hamas' Operation Al-Aqsa Flood, statements from WEIRD leaders surfaced almost two months later. In contrast, on 8 October 2023, Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim urged Malaysians to "unanimously back" the Palestinian cause. Indonesian President Joko Widodo urged "the immediate end of war and violence" just three days after Operation Al-Aqsa Flood. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, on 12 October 2023, advocated for a "durable peace that produces a viable Palestinian State." Consequently, the timing of the condemnations from WEIRD leaders appears notably delayed and ill-timed. Denunciations recently made by a handful of WEIRD leaders also came after numerous acts that displayed unwavering support for Israel's atrocities, which, in turn, exacerbated Israel's overboard use of force against Palestinians. In a joint statement published on 9 October 2023, President Macron of France, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, United Kingdom (UK) Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, and United States of America (US) President Joe Biden declared that they "support Israel in its efforts to defend itself and its people against such atrocities." The joint statement was followed by the UK abstaining and the US rejecting and vetoing a UN Security Council resolution on 18 October 2023 that would have condemned Hamas' attack on Israel, calling for a pause in the fighting to allow humanitarian assistance into Gaza, and legally bind all UN Member States, including Israel. On 27 October 2023, the UN General Assembly passed a non-binding resolution, calling for an immediate "humanitarian truce" between Israel and oPt and demanding aid access to Gaza. This time, Germany, Italy, and the UK abstained, while the US voted against the resolution. In an unsurprising move, a considerable number of WEIRD countries either refrained from voting or opposed the resolution, including Australia, Canada, Denmark, Iceland, the Netherlands, and Sweden. On 15 November 2023, a UN Security Council resolution was passed, calling for "urgent and extended humanitarian pauses and corridors throughout the Gaza Strip" to allow for aid delivery and medical evacuations, which the UK and the US abstained from. However, the resolution made no mention of a ceasefire and omitted Israel's retaliatory air strikes and ground offensive in Gaza, which currently have led to more than 1.6 million people being displaced in Gaza, and the death toll has surpassed 13,000, most of whom are Palestinians. Further, none of the condemnations made by WEIRD leaders addressed concerns that what Israel is doing against the Palestinians may amount to genocide. Under Article 6 of the Rome Statute, genocide is "acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial, or religious group." Since 7 October 2023, statements from Israeli officials have raised suspicions of genocidal intent towards Palestinians. On 9 October 2023, Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant referred to the Palestinians as "human animals." In the ICTY's Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic case, the use of derogatory terms towards the targeted group was considered evidence of genocidal intent, as seen in cases like the Rwandan genocide, where Tutsis were labeled as "cockroaches," and during the Holocaust, when Jews were termed a "cancer." Additionally, Israeli President Isaac Herzog said on 13 October 2023 that "an entire nation" is responsible for Israel's retaliations and insinuated that Palestinian households possessed missiles. Defending Israel's offensive strategy, Herzog argued, "When you have a missile in your goddamn kitchen, and you want to shoot it at me, am I allowed to defend myself?" On 29 October 2023, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu invoked the biblical story of Amalek to justify the killing of Gaza residents. Referring to the Holy Bible in 1 Samuel 15:3, Netanyahu stated, "Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and donkey." The Prosecutor v. Casimir Bizimungu case in the ICTR highlighted that even if a speech lacks an explicit appeal to commit genocide, it may still constitute direct incitement to genocide in a specific context as long as the speech is not considered ambiguous. Lastly, the condemnations appear notably hypocritical, especially considering the direct involvement of WEIRD countries in the alleged genocide. On 9 October 2023, UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak declared the UK's commitment to offering "diplomatic, intelligence, or security support," leading to the subsequent deployment of P8 aircraft, surveillance assets, two Royal Navy ships, three Merlin helicopters, and a company of Royal Marines on 13 October 2023, aimed at providing deterrence and assurance. On 12 October 2023, Germany agreed to Israel's request to utilize two Heron TP combat drones. In a more recent development, on 3 November 2023, the US House of Representatives approved a plan allocating US$14.5bn in military aid for Israel. In conclusion, the recent condemnations by WEIRD leaders concerning Israel's actions in the oPt should be viewed within the broader context of their delayed responses, historical support for Israel, and the absence of addressing potential genocidal concerns. While these leaders express criticism, their actions, including political and military support and abstentions from critical UN resolutions, raise questions about the consistency and sincerity of their stance. Viltu birta grein á Vísi? Sendu okkur póst. Senda grein Átök í Ísrael og Palestínu Ísrael Palestína Bretland Sameinuðu þjóðirnar Bandaríkin Ástralía Kanada Danmörk Holland Svíþjóð Frakkland Þýskaland Malasía Indónesía Spánn Ríkisstjórn Katrínar Jakobsdóttur Mest lesið Umbætur á skólakerfinu. Hættum að ljúga. Hættum því alveg og hættum því strax Atli Harðarson Skoðun Er ég ömurlegt foreldri ef ég segi nei við barnið mitt? Stefán Þorri Helgason Skoðun Þátttökuverðlaun Þórdísar Ragnar Þór Pétursson Skoðun Seljum börnum nikótín! Hugi Halldórsson Skoðun Ákall til ESB-sinna: Hvar eru undanþágurnar? Einar Jóhannes Guðnason Skoðun Vindorkuvæðing í skjóli nætur Kristín Helga Gunnarsdóttir Skoðun Sundrung á vinstri væng Jökull Sólberg Auðunsson Skoðun Fjármálaráðherra búinn að segja A Ögmundur Jónasson Skoðun Hvar liggur ábyrgð hins fullorðna á hegðun ungmenna í samfélaginu? Rakel Guðbjörnsdóttir Skoðun Þegar samfélagið missir vinnuna Hrafn Splidt Þorvaldsson Skoðun Skoðun Skoðun Seljum börnum nikótín! Hugi Halldórsson skrifar Skoðun Sundrung á vinstri væng Jökull Sólberg Auðunsson skrifar Skoðun Þegar samfélagið missir vinnuna Hrafn Splidt Þorvaldsson skrifar Skoðun Akademískt frelsi og ókurteisi Kolbeinn H. Stefánsson skrifar Skoðun Hvar liggur ábyrgð hins fullorðna á hegðun ungmenna í samfélaginu? Rakel Guðbjörnsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Yfir hverju er verið að brosa? Árni Kristjánsson skrifar Skoðun Umbætur á skólakerfinu. Hættum að ljúga. Hættum því alveg og hættum því strax Atli Harðarson skrifar Skoðun Stjórnvöld sem fjárfestatenglar Baldur Thorlacius skrifar Skoðun Ákall til ESB-sinna: Hvar eru undanþágurnar? Einar Jóhannes Guðnason skrifar Skoðun Er ég ömurlegt foreldri ef ég segi nei við barnið mitt? Stefán Þorri Helgason skrifar Skoðun Vindorkuvæðing í skjóli nætur Kristín Helga Gunnarsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Þátttökuverðlaun Þórdísar Ragnar Þór Pétursson skrifar Skoðun Fjármálaráðherra búinn að segja A Ögmundur Jónasson skrifar Skoðun Hagfræði-tilgáta ómeðtekin Karl Guðlaugsson skrifar Skoðun Ótryggt aðgengi á Veðurstofureit Friðjón R. Friðjónsson skrifar Skoðun Stattu vörð um launin þín Davíð Aron Routley skrifar Skoðun Byggjum fyrir eldra fólk, ekki ungt Ólafur Margeirsson skrifar Skoðun Hlustum í eitt skipti á foreldra Jón Pétur Zimsen skrifar Skoðun Hugleiðingar um ástandið fyrir botni Miðjarðarhafs Örn Sigurðsson skrifar Skoðun Heildstætt heilbrigðiskerfi – hagur okkar allra Alma D. Möller skrifar Skoðun Vanþekking eða vísvitandi blekkingar? Hjörtur J. Guðmundsson skrifar Skoðun „I believe the children are our future…“ Karen Rúnarsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Mikilvægi félagasamtaka og magnað maraþon Þuríður Harpa Sigurðardóttir skrifar Skoðun Allt sem ég þarf að gera Dagbjartur Kristjánsson skrifar Skoðun Eldri borgarar – áhrif aðildar að Evrópusambandinu (ESB) Þorvaldur Ingi Jónsson skrifar Skoðun Meiri gæði og mun minni álögur - Hveragerðisleiðin í leikskólamálum Jóhanna Ýr Jóhannsdóttir,Sandra Sigurðardóttir,Dagný Sif Sigurbjörnsdóttir,Halldór Benjamín Hreinsson,Njörður Sigurðsson skrifar Skoðun Reykjavíkurborg stígur fyrsta skrefið í snjallvæðingu umferðarljósa! Einar Sveinbjörn Guðmundsson skrifar Skoðun Framtíðin í fyrsta sæti – mikilvægi forgangsröðunar á tillögum Kópavogsbæjar í grunnskólamálum Sigrún Ólöf Ingólfsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Notkun ökklabanda Guðmundur Ingi Þóroddsson skrifar Skoðun Skólaskætingur Þórdís Kolbrún R. Gylfadóttir skrifar Sjá meira
Over the recent weeks, several leaders from the WEIRD (White/Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Developed/Democratic) world have expressed criticism for Israel's indiscriminate attacks in the occupied Palestinian territory (oPt). On 10 November 2023, Belgian Prime Minister Alexander De Croo characterized Israel's actions in Gaza as "disproportionate." French President Emmanuel Macron echoed this sentiment on 11 November, stating that there was "no justification" for the bombings and saying a ceasefire would benefit Israel while recognizing Israel's right to protect itself. On 15 November 2023, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez called on Israel to halt the "indiscriminate killing of Palestinians" in Gaza. The following day, Iceland Prime Minister Katrín Jakobsdóttir said she was "horrified by the ongoing civilian deaths in Gaza" and condemned all breaches of international humanitarian law. Despite the apparent solidarity, it's crucial to scrutinize the context and actions accompanying these condemnations. Unlike non-WEIRD leaders who swiftly condemned Israel's disproportionate retaliatory actions following the 7 October 2023 Hamas' Operation Al-Aqsa Flood, statements from WEIRD leaders surfaced almost two months later. In contrast, on 8 October 2023, Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim urged Malaysians to "unanimously back" the Palestinian cause. Indonesian President Joko Widodo urged "the immediate end of war and violence" just three days after Operation Al-Aqsa Flood. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, on 12 October 2023, advocated for a "durable peace that produces a viable Palestinian State." Consequently, the timing of the condemnations from WEIRD leaders appears notably delayed and ill-timed. Denunciations recently made by a handful of WEIRD leaders also came after numerous acts that displayed unwavering support for Israel's atrocities, which, in turn, exacerbated Israel's overboard use of force against Palestinians. In a joint statement published on 9 October 2023, President Macron of France, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, United Kingdom (UK) Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, and United States of America (US) President Joe Biden declared that they "support Israel in its efforts to defend itself and its people against such atrocities." The joint statement was followed by the UK abstaining and the US rejecting and vetoing a UN Security Council resolution on 18 October 2023 that would have condemned Hamas' attack on Israel, calling for a pause in the fighting to allow humanitarian assistance into Gaza, and legally bind all UN Member States, including Israel. On 27 October 2023, the UN General Assembly passed a non-binding resolution, calling for an immediate "humanitarian truce" between Israel and oPt and demanding aid access to Gaza. This time, Germany, Italy, and the UK abstained, while the US voted against the resolution. In an unsurprising move, a considerable number of WEIRD countries either refrained from voting or opposed the resolution, including Australia, Canada, Denmark, Iceland, the Netherlands, and Sweden. On 15 November 2023, a UN Security Council resolution was passed, calling for "urgent and extended humanitarian pauses and corridors throughout the Gaza Strip" to allow for aid delivery and medical evacuations, which the UK and the US abstained from. However, the resolution made no mention of a ceasefire and omitted Israel's retaliatory air strikes and ground offensive in Gaza, which currently have led to more than 1.6 million people being displaced in Gaza, and the death toll has surpassed 13,000, most of whom are Palestinians. Further, none of the condemnations made by WEIRD leaders addressed concerns that what Israel is doing against the Palestinians may amount to genocide. Under Article 6 of the Rome Statute, genocide is "acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial, or religious group." Since 7 October 2023, statements from Israeli officials have raised suspicions of genocidal intent towards Palestinians. On 9 October 2023, Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant referred to the Palestinians as "human animals." In the ICTY's Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic case, the use of derogatory terms towards the targeted group was considered evidence of genocidal intent, as seen in cases like the Rwandan genocide, where Tutsis were labeled as "cockroaches," and during the Holocaust, when Jews were termed a "cancer." Additionally, Israeli President Isaac Herzog said on 13 October 2023 that "an entire nation" is responsible for Israel's retaliations and insinuated that Palestinian households possessed missiles. Defending Israel's offensive strategy, Herzog argued, "When you have a missile in your goddamn kitchen, and you want to shoot it at me, am I allowed to defend myself?" On 29 October 2023, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu invoked the biblical story of Amalek to justify the killing of Gaza residents. Referring to the Holy Bible in 1 Samuel 15:3, Netanyahu stated, "Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and donkey." The Prosecutor v. Casimir Bizimungu case in the ICTR highlighted that even if a speech lacks an explicit appeal to commit genocide, it may still constitute direct incitement to genocide in a specific context as long as the speech is not considered ambiguous. Lastly, the condemnations appear notably hypocritical, especially considering the direct involvement of WEIRD countries in the alleged genocide. On 9 October 2023, UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak declared the UK's commitment to offering "diplomatic, intelligence, or security support," leading to the subsequent deployment of P8 aircraft, surveillance assets, two Royal Navy ships, three Merlin helicopters, and a company of Royal Marines on 13 October 2023, aimed at providing deterrence and assurance. On 12 October 2023, Germany agreed to Israel's request to utilize two Heron TP combat drones. In a more recent development, on 3 November 2023, the US House of Representatives approved a plan allocating US$14.5bn in military aid for Israel. In conclusion, the recent condemnations by WEIRD leaders concerning Israel's actions in the oPt should be viewed within the broader context of their delayed responses, historical support for Israel, and the absence of addressing potential genocidal concerns. While these leaders express criticism, their actions, including political and military support and abstentions from critical UN resolutions, raise questions about the consistency and sincerity of their stance.
Umbætur á skólakerfinu. Hættum að ljúga. Hættum því alveg og hættum því strax Atli Harðarson Skoðun
Skoðun Hvar liggur ábyrgð hins fullorðna á hegðun ungmenna í samfélaginu? Rakel Guðbjörnsdóttir skrifar
Skoðun Umbætur á skólakerfinu. Hættum að ljúga. Hættum því alveg og hættum því strax Atli Harðarson skrifar
Skoðun Meiri gæði og mun minni álögur - Hveragerðisleiðin í leikskólamálum Jóhanna Ýr Jóhannsdóttir,Sandra Sigurðardóttir,Dagný Sif Sigurbjörnsdóttir,Halldór Benjamín Hreinsson,Njörður Sigurðsson skrifar
Skoðun Reykjavíkurborg stígur fyrsta skrefið í snjallvæðingu umferðarljósa! Einar Sveinbjörn Guðmundsson skrifar
Skoðun Framtíðin í fyrsta sæti – mikilvægi forgangsröðunar á tillögum Kópavogsbæjar í grunnskólamálum Sigrún Ólöf Ingólfsdóttir skrifar
Umbætur á skólakerfinu. Hættum að ljúga. Hættum því alveg og hættum því strax Atli Harðarson Skoðun